The GOP: No Guest Worker Program?

By. Domenico Maceri

There is no doubt that the vast majority of agricultural workers in the US are Latinos. Many don’t have legal papers.  Because of the difficulties of getting enough people to pick fruits and vegetables, agricultural interests have been pushing for a guest-worker program.

That’s what President George Bush has proposed. Yet, the Republican Party is against it, holding to its position that the emphasis needs to be on controlling the borders as the country tries to solve the immigration problem.

That was the message sent by the “Border Enforcement Bill” passed by the House of Representatives in December of 2005. The bill focuses on preventing people from getting into the US and tries to flush out illegal immigrants from the workforce through requirements applied to employers. Approved mostly along party lines, the measure does not include a guest worker program.

Setting up a guest-worker program would be beneficial for business because it would provide a reliable source of cheap labor. The agriculture and service industries have become addicted to paying little above the minimum wage for menial work.

It happens with small companies which hire workers at street corners for a day of work.

Even major companies like Wal-Mart hire undocumented workers, typically indirectly, through the use of subcontractors.

Some farmers have been forced to advertise in Spanish language radio offering 10-12 dollar-an-hour wages. Even that is not enough to attract enough people to pick fruits and vegetables because it is very difficult work.

The shortage of workers has also come about because of other jobs available in construction. As soon as farm workers see that they can get steadier work in other areas that pays better, they leave. But even in construction it can be difficult to find Americans to do certain kinds of jobs. A Colorado contractor could not find people to dig ditches in spite of his $14-an-hour wages.

Bringing in people legally to do this kind of work would be a solution, yet that would mean doing something to deal with the estimated 11 million unauthorized people already in the US. Some have kids who are American citizens, some have businesses, and their deportation would be virtually impossible.

Bush is also not in a strong position to lead his party given his weak approval ratings, which are due to a large extent to the Iraqi war. However, a guest worker program which the right wing of the GOP would label “amnesty” would not be impossible to bring about.

Bush could easily find support for his proposal among Democrats who would quite likely support his proposal because it would benefit people already in the US.

A bill in the US Senate sponsored by John McCain (R-AZ) and Edward Kennedy (D-MA) would do much of what Bush has proposed.

Bush could thus work with moderate Republicans and Democrats to push the legislation through. It’s really the only way to solve the immigration dilemma.